-
Aviation Advisory
Our dedicated Aviation Advisory team bring best-in-class expertise across modelling, lease management, financial accounting and transaction execution as well as technical services completed by certified engineers.
-
Consulting
Our Consulting team guarantees quick turnarounds, lower partner-to-staff ratio than most and superior results delivered on a range of services.
-
Business Risk Services
Our Business Risk Services team deliver practical and pragmatic solutions that support clients in growing and protecting the inherent value of their businesses.
-
Deal Advisory
Our experienced Deal Advisory team has provided a range of transaction, valuation, deal advisory and restructuring services to clients for the past two decades.
-
Forensic Accounting
Our Forensic and Investigation Services team have targeted solutions to solve difficult challenges - making the difference between finding the truth or being left in the dark.
-
Financial Accounting and Advisory
Our FAAS team designs and implements creative solutions for organisations expanding into new markets or undertaking functional financial transformations.
-
Restructuring
Grant Thornton is Ireland’s leading provider of insolvency and corporate recovery solutions.
-
Risk Advisory
Our Risk Advisory team delivers innovative solutions and strategic insights for the Financial Services sector, addressing disruptive forces, regulatory changes, and emerging trends to enhance risk management and foster competitive advantage.
-
Sustainability Advisory
Our Sustainability Advisory team works with clients to accelerate their sustainability journey through innovative and pragmatic solutions.
-
Asset management Asset management of the futureIn today’s global asset management landscape, there is an almost constant onslaught of change and complexity. To combat such complex change, asset managers need a consolidated approach. Read our publication and find out more about what you can achieve by choosing to work with us.
-
Internal Audit Maintaining Compliance with New EU Pension Directive IORP IIOn 28 April 2021, the Irish Government transposed IORP II (Institution for Occupational Retirement Provision), an EU directive on the activities and supervision of pension schemes, into law.
-
Risk, Compliance and Professional Standards FRED 82 – Periodic Updates to FRS 100 – 105The concept of a new suite of standards for the UK and Ireland, aligning with international financial reporting standards, was first conceived in 2002
-
Audit and Assurance Auditor transition: how to achieve a smooth changeoverAppointing new auditors may seem like a daunting task that will be disruptive to your business and a drain on the finance function. Nevertheless, there are a multitude of reasons to consider a change, including simply seeking a ‘fresh look’ at the business.
-
Corporate Tax
Our Corporate Tax team is made up of more than 40 highly experienced senior partners and directors who work directly with a wide range of domestic and international clients; covering Corporation Tax, Company Secretarial, Employer Solutions, Global Mobility and Tax Incentives.
-
Financial Services Tax
The Grant Thornton team is made up of experts who are fully up to date in terms of changing and evolving tax legislation. This is combined with industry expertise and an in-depth knowledge of the evolving financial services regulatory landscape.
-
Indirect Tax Advisory & Compliance
Grant Thornton’s team of indirect tax specialists helps a range of clients across a variety of sectors including pharmaceuticals, financial services, construction and property and food to navigate these complexities.
-
International Tax
We develop close relationships with clients in order to gain a deep understanding of their businesses to ensure they make the right operational decisions. The wrong decision on how a company sells into a new market or establishes a new subsidiary can have major tax implications.
-
Private Client
Grant Thornton’s Private Client Services team can advise you on all areas of financial, pension, investment, succession and inheritance planning. We understand that each individual’s circumstances are different to the next and we tailor our services to suit your specific needs.
Whether existence of a subsidiary in a Member State creates a fixed establishment of the parent company
The ‘Place of Supply’ rules –the rules that determine where, for VAT purposes, a supply of goods or services takes place are set out in the VAT Directive. These rules are then expanded in EU regulations that are designed to ensure a common interpretation of the VAT Directive throughout the EU. Article 44 of the Directive sets out the general rule for supplies of services and states that in a situation where the customer is a business, the place of supply of services is where the customer is established, has a fixed establishment or in the absence of either, where he usually resides. The implementing regulations then provide further details on how to determine where a person is established or has a fixed establishment.
In this case, Dong Yang is a Polish company with an establishment in Poland. Its customer, LG Display Ltd is established in South Korea. LG Display Ltd also has two subsidiaries in Poland (LG Poland and LG Poland Sales). Under the terms of the contract with LG Display Ltd, Dong Yang was required to provide services (the assembly of parts belonging to LG Display Ltd). Once the parts had been assembled, the goods were ‘shipped’ to LG Poland which, under a separate contract with LG Display Ltd, provided storage facilities and logistic services and when the goods were ‘complete’ they were then sold by LG Display Ltd to LG Poland Sales for onward supply to the EU market.
Although it was registered for VAT in Poland, LG Display Ltd advised Dong Yang that it did not have any business establishment or a fixed establishment in Poland and, in accordance with Article 44 general place of supply rule, Dong Yang considered that the place of supply was in South Korea where LG Display Ltd did have its establishment. However, the Polish tax authorities took the view that through its contractual arrangements with its subsidiaries in Poland, LG Display Ltd had an establishment in Poland and that Dong Yang’s services were, in fact, supplied to that Polish establishment. The Polish tax authorities thus sought to subject the supply of services to Polish VAT considering that the place of supply was Poland and not South Korea. Dong Yang appealed that decision and the Polish court sought clarification on the law from the Court of Justice.
In its judgment issued 7 May 2020, the Court of Justice has confirmed that Article 44 of the VAT Directive and Article 11(1) and Article 22(1) of the implementing regulations must be interpreted such that the existence of a permanent establishment of a company established in a third State cannot be deduced by a service provider simply because that company has a subsidiary there.
Moreover, the supplier cannot be required to make extensive enquiries into the contractual relationships and obligations between its customer in a third State and its subsidiaries in the Member State. The Directive and the implementing regulations require a taxable person to exercise a reasonable degree of care in determining the correct place of supply. However, this does not include seeking out and verifying inaccessible contractual relationships between his contracting party and that party’s subsidiaries.
Comment –determination of the place of supply is one of the fundamental requirements of the EU VAT system as it determines not only where the tax becomes chargeable, but also confirms which tax jurisdiction is entitled to collect the tax. Here, the Polish tax authority considered that, in light of the contractual arrangements and obligations that subsisted between LG Display Ltd and its Polish subsidiaries, (facts that were unknown to Dong Yang), Dong Yang’s supplies were, somehow made to a fixed establishment of LG Display Ltd in Poland and subject to Polish VAT. The Court of Justice has confirmed that the existence of a subsidiary in a Member State does not create a business establishment of the third State parent company. It also confirms that the supplier cannot be required to do more than take reasonable steps to determine the correct place of supply